Informação jurídica inteligente
 Brasil | +55 (11) 31 81 77 29

Como Pensar o Estatuto Ético dos Animais. O Primado da Imparcialidade na Teoria Moral de Tom Regan e a Crítica Ecofeminista

Document Citado por Related
Vincent
AutorManuel Teles
CargoDoutor em Filosofia da Natureza e do Ambiente, inves;gador do Centro de Filosofia da Universidade de Lisboa e professor de Filosofia.
Páginas121-138
!"#$#!%&'()*!#!&(+)+,+#!-+."#!/#(!)'.$).(0!#!%*.$)/#!/)!
.$%)*".)1./)/&!')!+&#*.)!$#*)1!/&!+#$!*&2)'!&!)!"*3+.")!
&"#4&$.'.(+)!
HOW TO THINK ETHICALLY ABOUT ANIMALS: THE PRIMACY OF IMPARTIALITY IN TOM REGAN´S
MORAL THEORY AND THE ECOFEMINIST CRITIC!
"#$%!&&&&&&&!
MANUEL TELES
"'()'*! +,! -./'0'12! 32! 42)(*+ 52! +! 3'! 6,7 .+8)+ 9!
.8:+0;<23'*! 3'! =+8)*'! 3+! -./'0'12! 32! >8.:+*0.323+! 3+!
?.07'2!+!@*'A+00'*!3+!-./'0'12B!
C,2./%!,28+D)+/+0E02@'B@)!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!#F=$"!.3%!GH@0%II'*J.3B'*<IKKKKLKKKMLNOMPLPMOQ!
%!
RESUMO%! C0)+! 2*;<'! @*'J(*2!+/(J.32*! '! @*')2<'8.0,'! J+8)*2/! R(+! 2! .,@2*J.2/.323+! 200(,+! 82!
)+'*.2! S;J2! 3'! 1/T0'A'! U',! F+<289! 2,@/2,+8)+! *+@()23'! J','! (,! 3'0! ,+/G'*+0! 3+A+80'*+0!
J'8)+,@'*V8+'0! 32! :2/'*2WX'! ,'*2/! 3'0! 28.,2.0B! Y+3.28)+! '! J'8A*'8)'! J',! 2! J*Z;J2! 320!
+J'A+,.8.0)209!:[*.20!J'80.3+*2W\+0!,+)2S;J20!0X'!2:28W2320!8'!0+8;3'!3+!+:.3+8J.2*!'0!,S*.)'0!32!
@+*0@+J;:2!*+<28.282! 0'7*+! '!,'3'!J','! 3+:+,'0! @+802*! '! +0)2)()'!,'*2/! 3'0! 28.,2.0! ]! /(5! 3'!
J'8J+.)'!3+!.,@2*J.2/.323+B
%)1)5*)(6"7)5&%!CJ'A+,.8.0,'9!^;J2!28.,2/9!$,@2*J.2/.323+9!U',!F+<289!_2/'*!.8+*+8)+B!
)8(+*)"+%! UG.0! 2*;J/+! 2.,0! )'!J/2*.A `! )G+! J+8)*2/!*'/+! 'A! .,@2*;2/.)`! .8! U',! F+<28a0!@G./'0'@G.J2/!
)G+'*`9!bG.JG! .0! /2*<+/`! :.+b+3! 20! '8+! 'A! )G+! 7+0)! J'8)+,@'*2*`! 3+A+80+0! 'A! )G+! ,'*2/! :2/(+! 'A!
28.,2/0B!Y+)2+)G.J2/! J'80.3+*2;'80! 2*+!,23+! )'! +,@G20.5+! )G+!,+*.)0! 'A! F+<28a0!)2c+! '8!G'b!b+!
0G'(/3!)G.8c! ,'*2//`! 27'()!28.,2/09! <.:+8! G.0!:.+b!'8! .,@2*;2/.)`9!.8! )G+! A2J+!'A! )G+! J*.;J.0,!A*',!
+J'A+,.8.0)!+)G.J.0)0B!
9&:6;#*/(%!CJ'A+,.8.0,9!68.,2/!+)G.J09!$,@2*;2/.)`9!U',!F+<289!$8G+*+8)!:2/(+B!
(,$<*.#0! MB!>,2! .8)*'3(WX'! ]! S;J2! *+<28.282%!2! J*Z;J2! 320! +J'A+,.8.0)20B! dB!6! .,@'*)V8J.2! 32!
.,@2*J.2/.323+!82! ,+)'3'/'<.2! 3+!F+<28B! QB!6! .8J/(0X'!3'0! '()*'0! 82! e(0;1J2WX'!3'0! 8'00'0! e(Z5'0!
,'*2.0B! fB! #0! *+R(.0.)'0! 32! .,@2*J.2/.323+B!gB!=','! @+802*! '! +0)2)()'! S;J'! 3'0! 28.,2.0B! NB! >,2!
J'80.3+*2WX'!182/%!'!2/J28J+!32!S;J2!*+<28.282B!OB!F+A+*h8J.2B!
=>,?@!ABCDEFGHIE!J!KLM@!DNO@BA@B@0!@!MDPLM@!F@Q!NMERN?ABAQC@Q!
U',! F+<28! @2*;/G2! J',! 2! ,2.'*.2! 3'0! 1/T0'A'0! J'8)+,@'*V8+'0! 20! ,+0,20!
200(8W\+0! 7[0.J20! 0'7*+! '! ,'3'! J','! 3+:+,'0! @+802*! +;J2,+8)+B! C,! 0(,29! +/+!
@*+00(@\+! R(+! '! ,S)'3'! 3+! *+0'/:+*! @*'7/+,20! ,'*2.0! @2002! 8+J+002*.2,+8)+! @+/2!
@*+0J*.WX'!*2J.'82/!3+!8'*,20!(8.:+*02.0!3+!J'83()2B!6!@*'@T0.)'9!'!1/T0'A'!"2/+!i2,.+0'8!
'A+*+J+!(,2!J2*2J)+*.52WX'!,+)2S;J2!32R(./'!R(+!J'80.3+*2!0+*!2!J'8J+WX'!3',.828)+ 32!
,'*2/.323+9!82!R(2/!2!)+'*.2!*+<28.282!0+!.80J*+:+!J/2*2,+8)+B!j+<(83'!i2,.+0'8%!!!
S
#!)*272/G'!3'0!)+T*.J'0!,'*2.09!3+!2J'*3'!J',!2!J'8J+WX'!3',.828)+9!S!'!3+!)'*82*!
+k@/ZJ.)20!J+*)20!)+'*.20!,'*2.09!3+0J*+:+*!2!0(2! (8.:+*02/.323+!+!)'*82*! :Z:.3'!'!0+(!@'3+*!
J'+*J.;:'B!='80+<(+L0+! .0)'!+k2,.8283'!2*<(,+8)'09!2:2/.283'!+:.3h8J.20!+! +0J*(;8283'!
*+/2W\+0!/T<.J20B !
M
U'32:.29!+0)2!J'8J+WX'!32!,'*2/.323+!A'.!0(e+.)2!2! (,!:.<'*'0'!2)2R(+! @*':+8.+8)+!
3+!(,2!,.8'*.2!3+!1/T0'A'09!3+!+8)*+!'0! R(2.0! 3+0)2J2,L0+! 20! 1/T0'A20! A+,.8.0)20B!C0)20!
2() '*2 0! @( <82,! @' *! (, 2! ,'*2/.323+! *23. J2/,+8)+! 3.A +*+ 8)+9! J+ 8)*232! 8'0!
*+/2J.'82,+8)'0!2A+;:'0!+! J'8J*+)'0!R(+!20! @+00'20! @'3+,!A',+8)2*!+8)*+!0.B!#! @*T@*.'!
F+<28!8X'! +0J2@'(! 2! +00+! 2)2R(+9! /28W23'! @'*! 2/<(,20! *+@*+0+8)28)+0!3+! (,2! J'**+8)+!
+,+*<+8)+!8'!0+.'! 3'!A+,.8.0,'%!'! +J'A+,.8.0,'B !600.,9!(,!7',!@'8)'!3+!@2*;32! @2*2!
d
'! +0)(3'! 3'! 0.0)+,2! S;J'! 3+! F+<28! J'80.0)+9! 8X'! 82! 2A+*.WX'! 320! 0(20! @*+0J*.W\+0!
8'*,2;:209! ,20! 28)+0! +,! )+8)2*! @+*J+7+*! 0+! 20! 200(8W\+0! ,+)'3'/T<.J20! R(+! +/+!
@*+00(@\+!+! 0(@'*)2! 82! +/27'*2WX'! 3+0020!@*+0J*.W\+0!0X'! 0(1J.+8)+,+8)+! *'7(0)20!@2*2!
*+0.0;*+,!]!J*Z;J2!320!+J'A+,.8.0)20B!
6J*+3.)2,'0!R(+!'!0X'9!+9! @2*2!,'0)*[L/'9!2/'8<2*L8'0L+,'0!82!2@'/'<.2! ,+)2S;J2!
3+0020! 200(8W\+0! ,+)'3'/T<.J209! @'.09! )2/! J','! '! 2()'*! 20! +8R(23*2! 82! 0(2! )+'*.29! 2!
2J+.)2WX'!32! :2/.323+! 3+0)20! S! e[! ,+.'! J2,.8G'!@2*2!'! 2J'/G.,+8)'! 320! 0(20! @*+0J*.W\+0!
8'*,2;:20B!
jX'! 3(*20! 20! 2J(02W\+0! R(+! 20! +J'A+,.8.0)209! J','! "+7'*2G! j/.J+*9! i'0+@G.8+!
"'8':'8! +! _2/! l/(,b''39!3.*.<+,! J'8)*2! F+<28B ! 4'! +8)+83+*! 3+0)20! 1/T0'A209! 2! S;J2!
Q
*+<28.282! *+@*+0+8)2! ,2.0! (,2! )+8)2;:2! 3.00.,(/232! @2*2! A25+*! @*+:2/+J+*! :2/'*+0!
,20J(/.8'0! J','! 2! .,@2*J.2/.323+9! 2! '7e+;:.323+! +! 2! e(0;W2! (8.:+*02/9! J'80.3+*23'0!
0(@+*.'*+0! +! @*',':.3'0! @+/2! )*23.WX'! @2)*.2*J2/! :.<+8)+9! +,! 3+)*.,+8)'! 3+! :2/'*+0!
A+,.8.8'0! J','! 2! J',@2.kX'9! 2! 0(7e+;:.323+! +! 2! /.<2WX'! 2A+;:2B! 4+0)+0! ,'/3+09! 20!
+J'A+,.8.0)20!.8J.)2,! ]! *+0.0)h8J.2! J'8)*2! 2! ,.0'<.8.2! R(+! ,2*<.82/.52! '0! @23*\+0! S;J'0!
!4'! '*.<.82/%! mUG+! e'7! 'A! ,'*2/! )G+'*.0)09! '8! )G+! 3',.828)! J'8J+@;'89! .0! )'! ,2c+! @2*;J(/2*! ,'*2/! )G+'*.+0! +k@/.J.)9!)'!
M
3+0J*.7+!)G+.*! (8.:+*02/.)`9!283! )'! ,2c+!:.:.3! )G+.*! J'+*J.:+!@'b+*B!UG.0! .0! 3'8+! )G*'(<G!+k2,.8.8<! 2*<(,+8)09!200+00.8<!
+:.3+8J+9!283!0J*(;8.5.8<!/'<.J2/!*+/2;'80G.@0Bn!i6Y$Cj#49!"B9!Y+)G'3!283!,'*2/!)G+'*`B!$8!lB!j.8<+*!o+3Bp9!6!=',@28.'8!)'!
C)G.J09!#kA'*3%!q/2Jcb+//!l(7/.0G+*09!MrrM9!@B!fOOB
! #! +J'A+,.8.0,'!o'(! A+,.8.0,'! +J'/T<.J'p! 8X'! S! (,! ,':.,+8)'! ,'8'/Z;J'B! l2*2! (,2! 2@*+J.2WX'!320! 0(20! 3.A+*+8W20!
d
.8)+*8209!:+*9!@'*!+k+,@/'9!l?>Ys##"9!_B9!4N?ABAQ?!@BF!CTN! $@QCNDU!ER!'@CGDN9!?'83'8I4+b!t'*c%!F'()/+3<+9!MrrQ9!@@B!
dfLfKB
!=AB!j?$=CF9!"B9!:EGD!/@GOTCND!ED!:EGD!/EOB!Hypa<a!N9!8'B!M9!MrrM9!@@B!MKPLMdfu!"#4#_#49!iB9!)BA?@V! *AOTCQ!@BF!4N?ABAQC!
Q
+TNEDUB!$8!vB!v22*3!o+3Bp9!Ecofeminism: Women, Animals, Nature9!lG./23+/@G.2%! U+,@/+!>8.:+*0.)`!l*+009!MrrQ9!@@B!MNOLMrfu!
+!l?>Ys##"9!_B9!4N?ABAQ?!@BF!CTN!$@QCNDU!ER!'@CGDN9!?'83'8I4+b!t'*c%!F'()/+3<+9!MrrQ9!@@B!MNN9!MOMLMOQB
*NWAQC@!8D@QAVNAD@!FN!/ADNACE!)BA?@VX!W>!=YX!B>!=X!Z>!=6=[X!\@B>]?@AE!S^SS!

Para continuar a ler

PEÇA SUA AVALIAÇÃO

VLEX uses login cookies to provide you with a better browsing experience. If you click on 'Accept' or continue browsing this site we consider that you accept our cookie policy. ACCEPT